• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About
    • About RAA
    • Meet Sherry Truhlar
    • What makes us unique
    • Reviews/Clients
    • Press
    • Licensing
  • Contact
  • Client Login

Fundraising gala auctioneer Sherry Truhlar

  • Services
    • Onsite Auction Services
    • Fund a Need Experts
    • Consulting
    • Onsite workshops
  • Products
    • $10 Trainings
    • On Demand Webinars
    • Books
  • Speaking
    • Why Sherry
    • Keynote and Other Topics
    • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Free Resources
    • Newsletter
    • Auction Item Guide™
    • Recording: Porch Parties
    • Benefit Auction Case Study
    • Blog
  • Store
You are here: Home / Blog Post / Fake charity auction memorabilia raises problems
Jul 08

Fake charity auction memorabilia raises problems

Sherry Truhlar 4 Comments

fake-at-fundraisers

This Cincinnati news station did an in-depth review of the charity auction rock memorabilia market.

How would you handle this sad situation?

Visualize your gala. You’ve worked hard to acquire items, and your guests are milling through a large auction. Some of the items are the local sorts of donations one often sees at events in your area. Other items are more glamorous because you’ve worked with a memorabilia company to bring in “big ticket” items.

Guests are ogling and bidding on the merchandise, buying signed guitars from their favorite bands and snapping up memorabilia signed by celebrities. The auction is buzzing with excitement and you’re raising thousands of dollars.

After your gala, the local news station does an in-depth feature on your event and shows the world that virtually all of the memorabilia you presented as being “real” was fake, even those with the “Certificates of Authenticity” attached on the back.

What do you do?

  • Do you offer to reimburse your guests? (The charity offered to do this.)
  • Do you take the consignor to court?
  • Do you decide to try a different consignment company the following year? (But how do you know the merchandise is legit?)
  • Do you hire a good P.R. firm?

I’m going to let the newsreel speak for itself, but here’s the short of it: The fake memorabilia market is larger than the real memorabilia market. This puts you in a precarious position if your nonprofit is selling signed rock memorabilia in your auctions. Who do you trust?

Stories like this are why some of my clients “just say no” to memorabilia. A few take an even more aggressive stance, refusing to accept anything – memorabilia or not – if the item has a price attached to its sale. If it’s consigned, it’s not in their auction.

As I’m not a signature or memorabilia expert, this is one area where I can’t help my clients. Outside of sharing information like this story, I can’t authenticate a piece for them or verify that a particular company has legitimate merchandise.

It’s fun to have charity auction memorabilia in the auction, isn’t it? It can be exciting to bring in some of the pieces.  But this presents the downside of the industry, too. All food for thought.

Here’s the page to the complete story:

http://www.fox19.com/story/24831988/experts-say-the-fake-memorabilia-worth-millions-every-year

Got any insights? Share them below.

Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on LinkedIn Share
Send email Mail
Copyright © 2014 Red Apple Auctions Co. All Rights Reserved

About Sherry Truhlar

Fundraising auctioneer and educator, helping schools and nonprofits plan more profitable benefit auctions. A prolific writer for her own blog and other fundraising sites, she’s been covered in The Beacon-News, Town & Country Magazine, The Washington Post Magazine, Northern Virginia Magazine, Wiley's Special Events Galore!, AUCTIONEER, and other publications.

Reader Interactions

Easy tip to help activate sponsorship benefits: Show and Tell
Inspiration: Sharing my personal story of personal transformation

Comments

  1. Jen Kraft says

    November 10, 2015 at 7:26 PM

    We’re VERY lucky in the Milwaukee area. Jeff Lemieux of Jeff’s Sports on Capitol Drive in Brookfield, Wisconsin is reputable and trustworthy, and will NOT steer anyone wrong in his work helping out with consignment pieces. I trust Jeff, and so does everyone else. Class act!

    Reply
    • Sherry Truhlar says

      November 11, 2015 at 11:07 AM

      That’s great that you have someone you trust, Jen! What I took away from the research was that it’s tricky for a single person (a consignor, in this case) to be an expert in all signatures and memorabilia; it’s such a big industry and there’s simply so much of it. It’s hard to become an expert in every signature … every band … every celebrity. Consequently, even without intending to, some good folks might distribute fakes.

      Last week I worked an event where a signed musical instrument with a certificate of authenticity from the performer had been donated by an individual. It “looked” legit. But in this case, it was donated by an individual — not a consignor. This makes it even more difficult because I often see these types of pieces get bought at one gala and then donated to another gala. The nonprofit accepts the donation, assuming the piece is real. But from this article, I’d place my bets on saying that it wasn’t authentic.

      It’s tricky all around, isn’t it?

      Reply
  2. Sue Ellen says

    July 8, 2014 at 9:40 PM

    Hi Sherry – I would say that items like this are too hot to handle unless you have someone with an actual relationship with the star. Much like art, the item is only as good as the provenance. As shown here, a certificate of authenticity isn’t enough; you need to know the circumstance/history of the acquisition. Thanks for sharing this eye-opening story! (And don’t you wonder how the people at that Coach’s Corner Sports Auction sleep at night?)

    Reply
    • Sherry Truhlar says

      July 8, 2014 at 10:27 PM

      Hey there, Sue Ellen! Seeing your name pop up on my blog made me smile. Good input, as I’d expect from you. Cheers!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Connect with Me Here

What auction planners say

Sherry, oh, Sherry! You were an invaluable asset to this year’s gala. With your assistance we were able to add so many new elements that truly made a difference in taking our event to another level. This year was the most successful yet! Everyone loved you and the amazing energy that you brought to the event. We look forward to having you again in 2018!

Krystal Fenwick
Read more testimonials

Thank you so much for the outstanding job you did for us on April 1! I have received so much positive feedback from so many who attended. You even earned Sister Suzan’s (our Vice-Principal) seal of approval! Safe travels to all your many events and thank you for making our biggest fundraiser of the year our best ever!

Diane Albano, Director of Development
St. Joseph Academy Catholic High School (St. Augustine, FL)
Read more testimonials

Sherry is flexible and easy to work with. She gives honest feedback and advice throughout the planning and implementation process. Without a doubt, Sherry and Red Apple Auctions has helped take our annual fundraising event to the next level.

Beckie Middendorf, Development Director and Janet Gulla, Development Coordinator
St. Henry District High School (Erlanger, KY)
Read more testimonials

Sherry is “on board” from day one of auction planning, works closely with our steering committee and is only just a phone call away. The night of the auction, we toss her the keys and let her drive the event! We are never disappointed!

Charly Ryan, Director of Institutional Advancement
The Academy of the Holy Cross (Kensington, MD)
Read more testimonials

I was very fortunate to have Red Apple on board for my first auction. Working with Sherry was invaluable. She provided guidance at every phase of planning, from procurement on forward – and she challenged us to make our event more ambitious and more successful at every stage. Thank you, Sherry!

Pete Goldlust, Director of Development
Oak Hill School (Eugene, OR)
Read more testimonials

If your auction needs to upgrade, call any auctioneer you find on Google. But if you want your auction to be impressive, meaningful, and profitable, you need to call Sherry.

Erin Banda
2016 NYUMBANI Board member
Read more testimonials

The auction was entertaining .. proactive … the crowd was involved and felt a part of it,” he said, emphasizing, “The entertainment value was huge.

Darrell, a long-time attendee
Read more testimonials

We plan on booking Red Apple Auctions much earlier for our next event so we can take advantage of more of the pre-event offerings.

Nicole Carr, Director of Grants and Special Events
The Ivymount School (Rockville, MD)
Read more testimonials

Sherry, personally, I can’t even begin to tell you the immense amount of positive feedback that I received having YOU (and Darby) there with is this year! Some of the tidbits: You added EXCITEMENT and ENTERTAINMENT… You added EXPERTISE and FUN… You helped the evening FLOW, in a wonderful and positive direction… You were FUN,… Read The Rest “Anne Livaudais Knudsen, 5th year gala co-chair”

Read more testimonials

Aren’t KK and Michael a cute couple? They liked that I “moved the crowd along … kept the crowd engaged but wasn’t obtrusive or invasive. We were able to talk but still keep track of what was going on.”

Read more testimonials

You have NO idea of how many people came up to me (I know Julie as well) and said, ‘That auctioneer was incredible … she engaged the crowd, … she got the bidders to bid without being rude/pushing, … I loved observing her, I just watched her, … she did a great job.’ It was… Read The Rest “Staci Meruvia”

Read more testimonials

Geri said: “Great job of getting potential donors in the room to step up to the plate and not feel guilty or bad about it. They actually wanted to give more … and that’s not something I’ve seen in many other auctioneers.” The following year, she herself ‘stepped up’ and became one of the gala… Read The Rest “Geri”

Read more testimonials

Irene attended one of my New Hampshire auctions and assumed I must be a radio personality — until I started to chant that fast talk. “I’ve been to this event before with a couple of other auctioneers,” she said, “Your ability to get personal with people in a way that isn’t intimidating — men, women,… Read The Rest “Irene”

Read more testimonials

Most product & consulting remarks are found on their respective webpages, but I’ve listed two below so you’re assured my products are as spot-on as my auctioneering.   Not only was our 2013 auction a blast, but our Washington, D.C. public school raised $67,000 — that’s $25,000 more than last year! The evening went off… Read The Rest “Carolyn Kahn-Hall and Andrea Del Vecchio”

Read more testimonials

As a former Fox News Anchorwoman, I am often called on to perform at auctions. So, I know first-hand that auctioneering can be a difficult job. Sherry Truhlar is one of the best in the business. She is skillful at managing an audience and keeping them focused on the task at hand – which is… Read The Rest “Cynthia Steele Vance”

Cynthia Steele Vance
Guest at The Potomac School 2014 auction (McLean, VA)
Read more testimonials

home | auctioneering | consulting | free item guide | about

 

Red Apple Auctions Co., PO Box 6066, Arlington, VA 22206
Toll free: 888-474-0838 | Email: Info@RedAppleAuctions.com | Copyright © 2005 - 2018

 

Sherry Truhlar • Charity Auctions • School Auctions • Fundraising Auctions • Auction Galas • Benefit Auctions

 

Terms of Use · Privacy Statement