• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About
    • About RAA
    • Meet Sherry Truhlar
    • What makes us unique
    • Reviews/Clients
    • Press
    • Licensing
  • Contact
  • Client Login

Fundraising gala auctioneer Sherry Truhlar

  • Services
    • Onsite Auction Services
    • Virtual Auction Services
    • Fund a Need Experts
    • Consulting
    • Onsite workshops
  • Products
    • $10 Trainings
    • On Demand Webinars
    • Books
  • Speaking
    • Why Sherry
    • Keynote and Other Topics
    • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Free Resources
    • Webinar: COVID-19
    • Virtual Gala Cheat Sheet
    • Newsletter
    • Auction Item Guide™
    • Recording: Porch Parties
    • Benefit Auction Case Study
    • Blog
  • Store
You are here: Home / Administration / Benefit Auctions v. Online Nonprofit Contests: Where’s the payoff?
Jul 12

Benefit Auctions v. Online Nonprofit Contests: Where’s the payoff?

Sherry Truhlar 13 Comments

Benefit auctions Pam signage

Neighbor Pam uses signs, emails, and list serves to marshal support for her competition in the Sears Chef Challenge.

Recently a number of my benefit auction clients have been participating in online contests for nonprofits.

Most of them are not feeling “warm and fuzzy” when the contest ends.

“Don’t even mention the word “Pepsi” to me,” said one, who was exhausted after coming *that* close to winning thousands in the Pepsi Refresh challenge, only to lose by a handful of last-minute online votes to a competing nonprofit.

Then she said something I’ve also heard from others:

“With so much time having been devoted to getting the word out to our supporters to vote, I feel that we’re now behind in planning for our annual benefit auction.”

Yikes!

Benefit auctions are reliable income. If you’ve been operating one for a few years, you can – with relative accuracy – plan for the amount you want to raise. Using tested formulas, your auction can become dependable income for a group.

But contests?

Not so reliable.

benefit auctions v. online nonprofit contests - sign on corner for Pam

Posting signs at well-traveled intersections is how Pam is helping her campaign.

It’s almost like hearing your friend invested $100,000 in lottery tickets instead of buying the house he’d been admiring.  I’m sure you’d say, “You … did … WHAT?!?”

Contests are chances.

Sure, by following guidelines, you can improve your odds at winning (recall that Red Apple Auctions team member Julie regularly wins huge sweepstakes, and enjoys trips around the world), but there is no guarantee.

Some of the strategies individuals use to win contests isn’t much different than what a nonprofit could use to marshal support.

For instance, in my own condominium community of 1600 units, I’ve been voting for one of my neighbors as she competes in the Sears Chef Challenge.

I don’t know Pam, but she’s been sending out posts on our community listserve and posting signs around the area to turn out the vote.

(Or “turn on the vote, as it were, given that this is an online contest.)

Some of the strategies are similar.

  • Sending an email reminder to vote every day (if voting is allowed every day).
  • Encourage fans to ask their friends to vote, too.
  • Offer your fans an incentive to advertise on behalf of your submission.  (You can create a “contest within a contest.” Maybe the individual who refers the most votes wins two free tickets to your annual benefit auction?)

But boy, I hate the idea of spending loads of staff time on a contest if it’s competing with the planning of your auction.  The auction is a “sure thing;” the contest is a chance.

My advice: See if the contest work can be given to a volunteer or intern. Maybe someone like our Julie, who has a knack for it.

Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on LinkedIn Share
Send email Mail
Copyright © 2010 Red Apple Auctions Co. All Rights Reserved

About Sherry Truhlar

Fundraising auctioneer and educator, helping schools and nonprofits plan more profitable benefit auctions. A prolific writer for her own blog and other fundraising sites, she’s been covered in The Beacon-News, Town & Country Magazine, The Washington Post Magazine, Northern Virginia Magazine, Wiley's Special Events Galore!, AUCTIONEER, and other publications.

Reader Interactions

Here’s an easy charity auction tip – Use surveys
Chicago benefit auctions – Submissions due for BizBash awards

Comments

  1. Marita says

    August 2, 2010 at 6:04 PM

    I agree Sherry, an online contest can be useful for marketing purposes, but it is – after all – only a contest. PepsiRefresh is currently giving away $1.3 million every month, but for a smaller organization to win seems pretty much impossible. For smaller groups it does make sense to put resources into a project that has a more measurable outcome.

    PS: we’d love to publish a guest post of yours about fundraising auctions on FundraisingIP.com!

    Reply
    • Sherry says

      August 15, 2010 at 2:57 PM

      Hi Marita – Thanks for visiting. Seems as though your comment was directed into our blog’s trash bin so I just now saw the post. We’ll check out the website and be in touch!

      Reply
  2. Lori L. Jacobwith says

    July 14, 2010 at 9:23 AM

    Betsy, One tip for folks who have poured their time into a contest and not won is to let all those supporters know how close you came and what you would have done with the winnings. Then, invite their support with a quick emotional story about someone waiting for your services…make it easy to make a gift of any size. Turn those excited supporters in donors even if it’s a small gift. And then take GOOD care of them until you invite another gift later in the year.

    Reply
  3. Gerald Hundt says

    July 13, 2010 at 9:16 PM

    I am not a believer in either one, auctions can work, contests, usually the benefit other than the charity ie. Pepsi. I prefer raising money the old fashioned way, ask for it! It works and if managed effectively there is no donor burn out with multiple asks.

    Reply
    • Lisa Patterson says

      July 14, 2010 at 8:14 AM

      Gerald, you are right, all parts of a development plan need to be integrated so the donor’s experience is positive throughout the life of their relationship with a non-profit. When done properly, fundraising auctions have the ability to make development oh-so-much easier. Put 300 people in a room and give them a powerful group experience; non-profits will see that the synergy creates a energy-rich, memorable event. That experience makes it easier to secure “the really big money” in the months that follow.

      Reply
  4. Barbara P says

    July 13, 2010 at 1:54 PM

    Having just participated in the Chase Community Giving contest on Facebook this is particularly relevant. In my opinion – contests shouldn’t take the place of planned fundraisers. However, depending on the contest – it may well be worth some investment. In the case of Chase – 200 non-profits won – including us. While we didn’t get the ‘grand prize” we did win $20,000. It was a dedicated volunteer who drove it and that helped alot. I would though avoid those contests with one or two winners that tend to just leave a “bad taste”.

    Reply
    • admin says

      July 13, 2010 at 2:17 PM

      Barbara – Congrats! That’s wonderful. And thanks so much for sharing the inspiration. 🙂 I’m glad you had a volunteer “running the show,” so to speak as it sounds like a strategy others can follow.

      Reply
  5. Sandy Rees says

    July 12, 2010 at 10:34 PM

    I’m right with you Sherry. I’d rather see nonprofits spend their precious resources of time and money focusing on things that will work for them, not chasing rainbows.

    Thanks for verbalizing this – I’ll be sharing with some of my followers!

    Sandy Rees, CFRE

    Reply
    • admin says

      July 12, 2010 at 11:05 PM

      Ah, but those “lottery tickets” (contests) can be tempting, eh?

      Reply
  6. Betsy Baker says

    July 12, 2010 at 8:46 PM

    Sherry, great information! It sounds like you know your business well – I’ll look forward to reading more from you.

    Reply
    • admin says

      July 12, 2010 at 8:51 PM

      Thanks for stopping by, Betsy. Welcome to the blog.

      Reply
  7. Roger Carr says

    July 12, 2010 at 3:18 PM

    Contests can stir up excitement that will provide additional funds and supporters. However, your caution is right on target. I am excited that you suggested using volunteers as a way to compete without taking away too much time from staff.

    One thing you did not mention is that there has been some controversy around some of the online contests regarding fairness. Be sure to read and understand the rules before jumping in.

    Reply
    • admin says

      July 12, 2010 at 3:52 PM

      Great add-on, Roger. Reading the fine print is no doubt the first order of business!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Connect with Me Here

What auction planners say

Sherry, oh, Sherry! You were an invaluable asset to this year’s gala. With your assistance we were able to add so many new elements that truly made a difference in taking our event to another level. This year was the most successful yet! Everyone loved you and the amazing energy that you brought to the event. We look forward to having you again in 2018!

Krystal Fenwick
Read more testimonials

Thank you so much for the outstanding job you did for us on April 1! I have received so much positive feedback from so many who attended. You even earned Sister Suzan’s (our Vice-Principal) seal of approval! Safe travels to all your many events and thank you for making our biggest fundraiser of the year our best ever!

Diane Albano, Director of Development
St. Joseph Academy Catholic High School (St. Augustine, FL)
Read more testimonials

Sherry is flexible and easy to work with. She gives honest feedback and advice throughout the planning and implementation process. Without a doubt, Sherry and Red Apple Auctions has helped take our annual fundraising event to the next level.

Beckie Middendorf, Development Director and Janet Gulla, Development Coordinator
St. Henry District High School (Erlanger, KY)
Read more testimonials

Sherry is “on board” from day one of auction planning, works closely with our steering committee and is only just a phone call away. The night of the auction, we toss her the keys and let her drive the event! We are never disappointed!

Charly Ryan, Director of Institutional Advancement
The Academy of the Holy Cross (Kensington, MD)
Read more testimonials

I was very fortunate to have Red Apple on board for my first auction. Working with Sherry was invaluable. She provided guidance at every phase of planning, from procurement on forward – and she challenged us to make our event more ambitious and more successful at every stage. Thank you, Sherry!

Pete Goldlust, Director of Development
Oak Hill School (Eugene, OR)
Read more testimonials

If your auction needs to upgrade, call any auctioneer you find on Google. But if you want your auction to be impressive, meaningful, and profitable, you need to call Sherry.

Erin Banda
2016 NYUMBANI Board member
Read more testimonials

The auction was entertaining .. proactive … the crowd was involved and felt a part of it,” he said, emphasizing, “The entertainment value was huge.

Darrell, a long-time attendee
Read more testimonials

We plan on booking Red Apple Auctions much earlier for our next event so we can take advantage of more of the pre-event offerings.

Nicole Carr, Director of Grants and Special Events
The Ivymount School (Rockville, MD)
Read more testimonials

Sherry, personally, I can’t even begin to tell you the immense amount of positive feedback that I received having YOU (and Darby) there with is this year! Some of the tidbits: You added EXCITEMENT and ENTERTAINMENT… You added EXPERTISE and FUN… You helped the evening FLOW, in a wonderful and positive direction… You were FUN,… Read The Rest “Anne Livaudais Knudsen, 5th year gala co-chair”

Read more testimonials

Aren’t KK and Michael a cute couple? They liked that I “moved the crowd along … kept the crowd engaged but wasn’t obtrusive or invasive. We were able to talk but still keep track of what was going on.”

Read more testimonials

You have NO idea of how many people came up to me (I know Julie as well) and said, ‘That auctioneer was incredible … she engaged the crowd, … she got the bidders to bid without being rude/pushing, … I loved observing her, I just watched her, … she did a great job.’ It was… Read The Rest “Staci Meruvia”

Read more testimonials

Geri said: “Great job of getting potential donors in the room to step up to the plate and not feel guilty or bad about it. They actually wanted to give more … and that’s not something I’ve seen in many other auctioneers.” The following year, she herself ‘stepped up’ and became one of the gala… Read The Rest “Geri”

Read more testimonials

Irene attended one of my New Hampshire auctions and assumed I must be a radio personality — until I started to chant that fast talk. “I’ve been to this event before with a couple of other auctioneers,” she said, “Your ability to get personal with people in a way that isn’t intimidating — men, women,… Read The Rest “Irene”

Read more testimonials

Most product & consulting remarks are found on their respective webpages, but I’ve listed two below so you’re assured my products are as spot-on as my auctioneering.   Not only was our 2013 auction a blast, but our Washington, D.C. public school raised $67,000 — that’s $25,000 more than last year! The evening went off… Read The Rest “Carolyn Kahn-Hall and Andrea Del Vecchio”

Read more testimonials

As a former Fox News Anchorwoman, I am often called on to perform at auctions. So, I know first-hand that auctioneering can be a difficult job. Sherry Truhlar is one of the best in the business. She is skillful at managing an audience and keeping them focused on the task at hand – which is… Read The Rest “Cynthia Steele Vance”

Cynthia Steele Vance
Guest at The Potomac School 2014 auction (McLean, VA)
Read more testimonials
Read more testimonials

home | auctioneering | consulting | free item guide | about

 

Red Apple Auctions Co., PO Box 6066, Arlington, VA 22206
Toll free: 888-474-0838 | Email: Info@RedAppleAuctions.com | Copyright © 2005 - 2020

 

Sherry Truhlar • Charity Auctions • School Auctions • Fundraising Auctions • Auction Galas • Benefit Auctions

 

Terms of Use · Privacy Statement